Sam Bahadur Movie Review: The biographical Sam Bahadur has good intentions.

Sam Bahadur Movie Review {2.5/5} & Review Rating.

Unveiling the Tapestry of Valor: A Comprehensive Exploration of “Sam Bahadur”

In the realm of Indian cinema, the biographical genre has often been a canvas for capturing the lives of extraordinary individuals who have left an indelible mark on the nation’s history. “Sam Bahadur,” the cinematic ode to India’s greatest soldier, Sam Manekshaw, aims to unravel the fascinating journey of a man whose life was etched with bravery, resilience, and unwavering commitment to the motherland.

Sam Bahadur Movie Review
Plot Unveiled:
The narrative unfolds in the year 1933, where Sam Manekshaw, portrayed with poignant depth by Vicky Kaushal, takes center stage as a corporal in the British Indian Army stationed in Mussoorie. Against the backdrop of pre-independence India, the film delicately intertwines the love story between Sam and Silloo (Sanya Malhotra), offering a glimpse into the personal sacrifices made by a man whose destiny would be forever entwined with the tumultuous history of the subcontinent.

As Sam rises through the Army ranks due to his valour and no-nonsense approach, the canvas expands to encompass the canvas of World War II. His heroic stand in Burma against Japanese troops, surviving seven gunshot wounds, serves as a testament to his indomitable spirit.

The film navigates through the partition era, presenting a pivotal moment when Sam, despite an offer to join the Pakistani Army, steadfastly opts to serve in the Indian Army. Post-independence, his journey continues, leading him to the role of Major General in Wellington, Tamil Nadu.

The Indo-China dispute emerges as a climactic juncture, bringing Sam face to face with the future Prime Minister of India, Indira Gandhi (Fatima Sana Shaikh). The subsequent narrative explores the uncharted territories of Sam’s life, forming the crux of “Sam Bahadur.”

Narrative Evaluation:
Bhavani Iyer, Shantanu Srivastava, and Meghna Gulzar embark on a commendable endeavor to encapsulate the rich tapestry of Sam Manekshaw’s life. While the story is undoubtedly compelling, the screenplay falls short of fully harnessing the potential high points that a life as illustrious as Sam’s inherently possesses. The film teeters on the brink of being a docudrama, meticulously documenting events but occasionally missing opportunities to infuse cinematic vibrancy.

However, the redeeming quality lies in the dialogue crafted by the trio, Bhavani Iyer, Shantanu Srivastava, and Meghna Gulzar. The dialogues inject the narrative with doses of drama and humor, adding layers to Sam’s character and creating moments that resonate with the audience.

Meghna Gulzar’s directorial prowess shines through her sincere attempt to narrate Sam Manekshaw’s story without succumbing to unnecessary embellishments. The director’s commitment to authenticity is evident as she avoids gratuitous drama, action, or dialoguebaazi, choosing instead to let the story unfold with a sense of purpose.

The film manages to capture Sam’s renowned sense of humor, a facet that becomes a thread weaving through memorable scenes, such as his brutal injury in Burma and the poignant bond shared with Yahya Khan (Mohd. Zeeshan Ayyub).

Despite commendable aspects, the film faces criticism for lacking a cinematic crescendo, particularly in the second half. The 1971 Indo-Pak war, serving as the climax, fails to deliver the expected emotional impact due to the docudrama execution, leaving the audience somewhat detached from Sam’s monumental achievements during this period.

Sam Bahadur's song Badhte Chalo
Performances that Transcend:
Vicky Kaushal’s portrayal of Sam Manekshaw emerges as the heart and soul of “Sam Bahadur.” The actor’s immersive performance not only breathes life into the character but also stands as a testament to his evolving craft. Kaushal’s dedication is evident in his nuanced portrayal, from body language to accent, marking this as the zenith of his acting career.

Sanya Malhotra and Fatima Sana Shaikh, though delivering fine performances, find themselves somewhat underutilized in roles that could have been more nuanced. Mohd. Zeeshan Ayyub’s portrayal, initially decent, loses some of its impact in the second half, leaving audiences wanting more from a character that holds promise. Neeraj Kabi as Jawaharlal Nehru and Govind Namdev as Sardar Patel offer solid performances despite their limited screen time.

However, it’s crucial to acknowledge that certain characters, like Govind Namdev’s Sardar Patel, are regrettably relegated to a single scene, limiting the potential depth they could have added to the narrative.


Technical Flourish:
The musical landscape, composed by Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy, unfortunately, fails to strike a resonant chord. Tracks like ‘Badhte Chalo’ and ‘Banda’ lack a shelf life, contributing little to the film’s overall impact. However, ‘Itni Si Baat’ stands out for its well-executed picturization, offering a brief respite from the forgettable tunes.

Ketan Sodha’s background score, on the other hand, proves instrumental in elevating the film’s emotional resonance. It subtly underscores crucial moments, providing a supportive framework to the narrative.

Cinematographer Jay I Patel’s lens paints a neat visual aesthetic, transporting audiences to the bygone era with finesse. The production design by Subrata Chakraborty and Amit Ray is meticulous, recreating historical settings with attention to detail.

Costume designers Sachin Lovelekar, Divvya Gambhir, and Nidhhi Gambhir successfully resurrect the fashion of the past, contributing to the film’s immersive experience. Parvez Shaikh’s action sequences, unobtrusive yet impactful, enhance the overall tone of the film. However, Nitin Baid’s editing could have been sharper, especially in the second half, where the pacing occasionally falters.

Critical Examination:
“Sam Bahadur” emerges as a well-intentioned biopic that shines a spotlight on a national hero. Vicky Kaushal’s stellar performance, supported by a competent cast, becomes the film’s crowning glory. While the film successfully delves into the remarkable life of Sam Manekshaw, it grapples with the challenge of balancing documentary-style storytelling with cinematic flair.

The second half, criticized for its lack of a cinematic crescendo, highlights the fine line between historical documentation and immersive storytelling. The execution of the 1971 Indo-Pak war, although historically accurate, fails to deliver the expected emotional punch, leaving the audience somewhat disconnected from the monumental achievements of Sam during this period.

The film’s potential at the box office faces a formidable opponent in the form of “Animal,” which may overshadow its prospects. While “Sam Bahadur” successfully introduces a new generation to the remarkable story of Sam, its legacy may hinge on the balance it strikes between historical accuracy and cinematic engagement.

Sam Bahadur's trailer
“Sam Bahadur” stands as a sincere tribute to a national hero, bringing Sam Manekshaw’s story to the forefront of cinematic narratives. Vicky Kaushal’s portrayal, coupled with the film’s meticulous attention to historical details, ensures that Sam’s legacy is celebrated on the silver screen.

While the film grapples with certain cinematic nuances, it succeeds in shedding light on the life of a man whose contributions to the nation deserve recognition. As “Sam Bahadur” navigates the challenges of the box office, its impact extends beyond mere entertainment, offering audiences a glimpse into the valorous journey of a man who truly earned the title of India’s greatest soldier.

Leave a comment